predestination or free choice, calvinism or armenianism (if you don't know, they mean the same thing). does God make everything happen, or do we make our own destinies? i don't know where you stand on the subject, but i was talking with my friend over the course of a week or so, and this is what i had to say on the topic. hope it helps answer some of your questions if you have any! if not, please ignore this post, as i'll hopefully be talking more about how much He's been doing in my life and less about little opinions i have. God bless y'all and i hope you enjoy!
friend 1: "Do you realize that what you are arguing for in Predestination is that God has strictly FORBIDDEN certain people from coming into his Kingdom? In John 3:16, John writes that 'God so loved the WORLD that He gave his one and only son, that WHOEVER believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life.' "
friend 2: I'm sorry if you believe that. Talk to me and I can correct thine ignorance ;)
friend 3: I have been studying Calvinism in depth for the past four to five years, know most of what there is to know about it, tried to become a Calvinist, and posed this question to every Calvinist I've met. This, in less bloated terms, is what the doctrine believes. No one has ever answered the question, and no other Calvinist has ever told me that I am misrepresenting their views.
me: well, if God is outside of time, space, and matter, He doesn't just set the world in motion and then decide who's gonna end up with Him and who isn't. God is. all the time, everywhere, etc. therefore, when God makes you, yes, He knows everything about you, and what you'll do with the life He gives you etc, but He also limits His power because He gives you the free will to choose the destiny He knows you will choose. so, it is a paradox. calvinism is very true in that God knows all things, including who will choose Him and who won't, who He has made and how they will turn out is known to Him and He still makes them. BUT it's also true that He gives them the free will to choose this fate, and won't push them in a certain direction that would interfere with this freedom of choice in a way that would inhibit the free will to choose Him (or not choose Him). so, free will is also utterly real. but ultimately, neither one matters all that much because the ultimate purpose of God is love. therefore, the point isn't whether you are predestined or whether you're given free will (you're given both). the point is that God gives you the full benefits of His love, loves you relentlessly, calls you in whatever way He knows is best, and you are given the chance to accept His love or not.
friend 3:I agree with Daniel completely!
That God knows, but God does not decide, who will chose him.
That is not, however, what Calvin believed.
Calvin held that He knows AND chose.
me: well, He kinda does both. God's all about paradox. like how He's all mercy and all justice at the same time, or how He's all grace and all truth at the same time. humans can't do both, so we go off and do one without the other or we try to "balance them both". God has no balance, he infinitely both. so yes, if He willfully creates a creature that He knows won't choose Him in the place and time He puts it in, and still creates it, He very much condemns or saves that creature, however, it is completely that creatures choice to accept His love or not, God completely limits His power and gives us free choice. so calvin was very much right (calvin also lived in a time when people were starting to talk about how man chose everything, and were attempting to continue things like purgatory etc where people were all in control - going off on the side of free will with no acceptance of God's predestined will - so calvin, who was also human, but was saved and knew his Bible, went off on predestination).
friend 2: Yay! Someone else who believes that we can't understand everything about how God works!!! :D
friend 3: way to be a diplomat daniel.
(he's still holding an armenian view (with God limiting his power to allow choice)...so not sure what that's about! hahaha =)
friend 2: JUST SO YOU KNOW, an "armenian" is from Armenia... an Arminian is a person who disagrees with Calvin. :P
Oh, what that's about is just punching a hole in the belief that you have to be 100% in either camp. :) There is plenty of midd...le ground, ya know. Most Baptists are actually 4 point Calvinists.
friend 3: I knew that! I'm not an arminian...I'm an Armenian disquised as an Arminian....if that makes sense...
Well...you're officially in one camp once you decide on the key issue, A. God predestines ppl to chose him. B. He doesn't. But anyway...com...e to the Armenian camp...forget about Arminians and Calvinists...we've got swords and cool accents! And marshmallows....
friend 2: Hahaha! Perfect sense. :)
Oh yes, I am definately in one camp... but not everyone is. :)
Hahaha! Yes, I am most definately an Armenian first, Calvinist second ;)
me: no guys! i must not be explaining this well... God is EXTREME! He utterly predestines someone. He decides where they are going, but He also gives them complete choice. it's the only way He can be in complete control all the time but still l...et us love Him and vice versa. this is not being diplomatic, or choosing a shade of gray, or saying that there is more than one truth. the utter truth of the matter is that God is an infinite being of immeasurable intensity, purpose, and freedom. if He didn't do both COMPLETELY and UTTERLY, He wouldn't be God. just like those who go on about God's judgment is coming, and how He will destroy evil completely and utterly and will leave no trace of evil or evil people behind, but leave out that He has given grace and mercy that is everlasting and all consuming and all healing are utterly wrong, so someone who says that God is only completely predestined or only completely chosen are wrong. neither is right individually, because God isn't just one extreme. He is both, the Greatest of Paradoxes. if we say He is one and not the other, or a little of both, or say that He might be one or the other, we lie and make Him out to be less than God...
friend 3: I stand corrected...apparently some people can believe both views In their entirety at the same time....though now I'm more confused than ever...
me: that's the point. you're human. you can't do both at the same time. He's God, He by nature has to do both completely and utterly all the time (and even outside of time). think about it; we can understand God, but can't comprehend Him. ...we can understand that there are numbers that go on for infinity, or that the sun is the size of over 1 billion earths put together, but can we really comprehend the extent of an infinite number or the size of something so overwhelmingly greater than anything we've experienced? in the same way, if something about God's nature isn't understandable, or is straight up contradictory, then you know it's false because God is so much smarter than we are, His logic should make sense, and He's never-changing, so He never contradicts Himself. but, if it is something that mankind can completely explain and rap its mind around, then you also know it can't be God because His mind must be bigger than our own, else, He isn't greater than we are and needn't be worshiped, or be God for that matter. He must make sense and know everything and make everything as it's meant to be (therefore dooming or saving His creation since He knows the end result of putting His creation in its particular body with its particular traits in its particular time) and therefore predestines His creation to Heaven (a relationship with Him) or Hell (the absence of that relationship). He also, however, must limit His power over the individuals soul and mind in order to give it free will to love or hate Him, since love must be chosen (or refused). He therefore creates His creatures destiny, but they are entirely in control of what they do - they make the destiny He places before them. it is completely theirs to decide, He simply allows them to choose it. so, you see, both are utterly true, understandable, and very much incomprehensible since no human mind could ever do both these things at the same time. and since the paradox of God's gift of free will and His all-controlling nature are understandable, but incomprehensible, it gives more evidence towards the fact that it's a God thing that only a perfect, all powerful, all loving God could do.
friend 3: Daniel, You are inferring the utterly impossible and illogical is what God did, which allows you to make two irreconcilable interpretations of the Bible true at the same time even tho they class on at least a thousand points ... and hence I... am unable to argue the point, as any attacks on your argument cannot be logical or Biblical.
I could return with the same exact argument, "our minds are finite, and you know those verses that seem to be about predestination?, the impossible is possible with God...and our minds don't understand it, but those verses are really about LAMAS and RANCH DRESSING! But God's mind is above our minds...and can make anything possible and beyond our mortal comprehension! " My view there is just as logical as yours then, and uses the same fallacious defense.
What is this view called anyway? Cause it sure ain't Calvinism or Arminienism. Maybe you could name it after that song, "You've got the beeeeeest of both worlds!"
:) Thanks for sharing! :)
friend 2:
Hahahahaha! Daniel, I love you! :D You say everything i want to so much better. :) Don't give up!
Ooh, don't insult his views with such absurd examples! Seriously, what he says makes perfect sense. The ultimate trend of the Bible fa...vors predestination; in other words, the number of verses (if interpreted literally) far outweigh the others. However, the other verses ARE there. No part of the Bible is false, so conclusion: they must both be true. :) Its like I said: Somehow it is 100% man's choice and 100% God's. Just because you're confused does not make it a fallacy. :)
me: my point was not that we can't understand that something that's contradictory isn't true. 2+2=5 is not and will never be true. it's that 3/9=0.3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333... and we can't comprehend how far that number goes, even if we understand that the number goes on for infinity (hence the ...).
tell me, can you forgive someone and judge their sin at the same time? when someone treats you horrible, beats you up, spits in your face or worse, can you, at the same time, condemn what they do and forgive them? if you are honest with God and with yourself, you will say NO! you can choose to forgive the person who wrongs you completely (and not hurt them at all since they are completely forgiven), or choose to judge their actions (and do justice to them and punish them for their actions since they were evil and deserve punishment). even if you choose to do one first and then the other (for example, if a parent punishes their child for doing something wrong but then forgives the kid) you cannot do both at the same time. you cannot, according to what you're saying, accomplish this feat, since the human being cannot do both at the same time. since, even though we can understand both forgiveness and punishment, we can't do them both at the same time, they must always and ever contradict each other. however, since you can't do it, since your mind, body, and spirit can't accomplish a paradoxical feat, you are also implying that God can't. God did in fact forgive us of our sins and conquer and judge the sinfulness of the world at the exact same time on a hill called golgatha a couple thousand years ago. sorry to bust your bubble, God judged your actions and made you liable to go to hell on that cross when He did something about the sin of the world and subjected Himself to the full deprivation, pain, suffering, and temptation of the human experience while still staying clean. like the Bible says, we are without excuse. but, on that cross, He also took all of the judgement planned for you, and made complete and utter forgiveness of sins a reality. think about it, God judged you to hell and freed your soul to heaven at the same time. see the difference between a contradiction and a paradox yet? if what you said in your last little snippet is true, God can't do both, so He is either way too good for us and we're all going to hell and completely deserve to be there, or we're all going to heaven to be with Him whether we like Him or not (no free choice). i'm assuming that you get that this line of thinking is wrong. God is a god of paradoxes. we can understand them, but we can't comprehend the extent or the way He does both at the same time. i can understand that He's right to judge me to death, and i can understand that i always have been and will always be completely forgiven, but it is impossible for me to wrap my mind around that fact. that both are, were, and always will be true.
now, what does that mean for our little talk? it means that just because we can't comprehend something, doesn't mean we can't understand it. secondly, to clarify, i'm not calvinist or amenian really. i'm simply making the point that there is utter predestination in the universe, but also utter free will.
to go back to your comment, you never really seem to get that there's a difference between not being able to wrap your mind around something and not being able to understand it. to go back to my example with math, 2+2 will never equal 5. but 3/9 will always equal 0.33333333333333333 (repeating). can you wrap your mind around an infinite number? i'm not saying, can you write out the equation and get the answer. can you really wrap your mind around the fact that that number has no end? never...
in your last comment, you simply said that i was trying to merge to views that were irreconcilable, and hence, i was illogical and there was no way to reply. in your analogy, you said that because God was greater than human minds, 2+2=5, your just not God so you don't get it. no where did i say anything of the sort. in fact, that was my whole point of explaining how we can't wrap our minds around the infinite. if the Bible said Jesus had shown up like the Jews thought he would (a military hero who would come down wreathed in flame and destroying the gentiles) it would have seemed like something man made up, not God. who would believe, before examining the evidence, that it made more sense for God, almighty, the infinite master of time, space, matter, and spiritual existence, would come onto a little spec of dust called earth to help a couple of insignificant microscopic specs called humans understand that God loved them? who would think that God would become a man before seeing how it worked out? that is impossible for us to wrap our minds around! i'm sorry, but the fact that He did that is mind-blowing! i can understand it's true, and i can understand that i'm forgiven of my sins because of it, but can i ever fully grasp it? no! and since i can't ever really grasp the depth of that sort of sacrifice, that i would never have come up with that sort of solution to the problem were i in that same position, i must conclude it comes from something higher than me (i.e. God).
in the same way, if i can understand that God is outside of time and makes us anyway, knowing what and who we are and what and who we will end up being, and that He is in complete control, and also understand that He limits His power over my soul and gives me the gift of free choice to ultimately choose the path He has put me on, but cannot in a million years wrap my mind around how He could do it (even though i can understand it) i must conclude that it is from God, not me.
soooooo.... if you've made it this far, i gotta say you're a trooper. like i said, this is like, a weeks worth of thought, so it's a bunch. i just wanted to hit the ground running after a long break from the blog, and i figured this was something i had handy that might help somebody. i know predestination and whether it's true or not can be a touchy subject - these are my thoughts and the thoughts of some of my very intellectual friends, not necessarily the truth. i also haven't finished the convo, so my friends on the other side(s) might have more to say. however, all of the stuff about the cross is utterly true! He loves you and He went all the way to prove it! if any of y'all are like me, you've been going through a low point spiritually (which i gotta talk about soon!). hold on to Him and His love. He'll getcha through!
God bless!
Ooh, don't insult his views with such absurd examples! Seriously, what he says makes perfect sense. The ultimate trend of the Bible fa...vors predestination; in other words, the number of verses (if interpreted literally) far outweigh the others. However, the other verses ARE there. No part of the Bible is false, so conclusion: they must both be true. :) Its like I said: Somehow it is 100% man's choice and 100% God's. Just because you're confused does not make it a fallacy. :)
me: my point was not that we can't understand that something that's contradictory isn't true. 2+2=5 is not and will never be true. it's that 3/9=0.33333333333333333333
tell me, can you forgive someone and judge their sin at the same time? when someone treats you horrible, beats you up, spits in your face or worse, can you, at the same time, condemn what they do and forgive them? if you are honest with God and with yourself, you will say NO! you can choose to forgive the person who wrongs you completely (and not hurt them at all since they are completely forgiven), or choose to judge their actions (and do justice to them and punish them for their actions since they were evil and deserve punishment). even if you choose to do one first and then the other (for example, if a parent punishes their child for doing something wrong but then forgives the kid) you cannot do both at the same time. you cannot, according to what you're saying, accomplish this feat, since the human being cannot do both at the same time. since, even though we can understand both forgiveness and punishment, we can't do them both at the same time, they must always and ever contradict each other. however, since you can't do it, since your mind, body, and spirit can't accomplish a paradoxical feat, you are also implying that God can't. God did in fact forgive us of our sins and conquer and judge the sinfulness of the world at the exact same time on a hill called golgatha a couple thousand years ago. sorry to bust your bubble, God judged your actions and made you liable to go to hell on that cross when He did something about the sin of the world and subjected Himself to the full deprivation, pain, suffering, and temptation of the human experience while still staying clean. like the Bible says, we are without excuse. but, on that cross, He also took all of the judgement planned for you, and made complete and utter forgiveness of sins a reality. think about it, God judged you to hell and freed your soul to heaven at the same time. see the difference between a contradiction and a paradox yet? if what you said in your last little snippet is true, God can't do both, so He is either way too good for us and we're all going to hell and completely deserve to be there, or we're all going to heaven to be with Him whether we like Him or not (no free choice). i'm assuming that you get that this line of thinking is wrong. God is a god of paradoxes. we can understand them, but we can't comprehend the extent or the way He does both at the same time. i can understand that He's right to judge me to death, and i can understand that i always have been and will always be completely forgiven, but it is impossible for me to wrap my mind around that fact.
now, what does that mean for our little talk? it means that just because we can't comprehend something, doesn't mean we can't understand it. secondly, to clarify, i'm not calvinist or amenian really. i'm simply making the point that there is utter predestination in the universe, but also utter free will.
to go back to your comment, you never really seem to get that there's a difference between not being able to wrap your mind around something and not being able to understand it. to go back to my example with math, 2+2 will never equal 5. but 3/9 will always equal 0.33333333333333333 (repeating). can you wrap your mind around an infinite number? i'm not saying, can you write out the equation and get the answer. can you really wrap your mind around the fact that that number has no end? never...
in your last comment, you simply said that i was trying to merge to views that were irreconcilable, and hence, i was illogical and there was no way to reply. in your analogy, you said that because God was greater than human minds, 2+2=5, your just not God so you don't get it. no where did i say anything of the sort. in fact, that was my whole point of explaining how we can't wrap our minds around the infinite. if the Bible said Jesus had shown up like the Jews thought he would (a military hero who would come down wreathed in flame and destroying the gentiles) it would have seemed like something man made up, not God. who would believe, before examining the evidence, that it made more sense for God, almighty, the infinite master of time, space, matter, and spiritual existence, would come onto a little spec of dust called earth to help a couple of insignificant microscopic specs called humans understand that God loved them? who would think that God would become a man before seeing how it worked out? that is impossible for us to wrap our minds around! i'm sorry, but the fact that He did that is mind-blowing! i can understand it's true, and i can understand that i'm forgiven of my sins because of it, but can i ever fully grasp it? no! and since i can't ever really grasp the depth of that sort of sacrifice, that i would never have come up with that sort of solution to the problem were i in that same position, i must conclude it comes from something higher than me (i.e. God).
in the same way, if i can understand that God is outside of time and makes us anyway, knowing what and who we are and what and who we will end up being, and that He is in complete control, and also understand that He limits His power over my soul and gives me the gift of free choice to ultimately choose the path He has put me on, but cannot in a million years wrap my mind around how He could do it (even though i can understand it) i must conclude that it is from God, not me.
the ultimate problem if predestination is all there is is much the same problem that one encounters if all the cross did was judge our sin. if God simply sets our paths, but never really gives us the choice to choose them or not, than He never loves us, and the aura of God is love, so we know this cannot be the case. if He only judges our sin, but never saves us, than He can never have a relationship with us (and can never love us, which He must do-see above point on the love nature of God), and we are all on our own and doomed.
however, if there is only free choice, if we all decide our own fate, and are untouchable, than God has no power, no control, and therefore is not God (since God must retain His power in order to forgive us, help us, etc.) if He has no power over our lives, than He cannot save us from evil, since that might at times limit our free will to choose Him or not. even though it appears that free choice without God's influence will get us where we need to be, it ultimately, on its own, isolates us from the Father since He will not interfere with our choice. the ultimate form of reality, if free choice is all there is, is deism, since God will not interfere in the lives of His creation, and since, we all like sheep have gone astray (isaiah), if we're on our own, to put it bluntly, we're all screwed. just like if all God did was forgive us on the cross, but never judge our sin, we would all go to heaven, no questions asked. at first this seems nice - everyone's going to heaven! but what does that really mean? heaven is where God is. it's the place where we ultimately know and love God and experience the true, infinite bliss of His love. but love requires a choice, and there was no choice in this redemption. so even though we're all saved, none of us are loved enough to choose it. it's flawed and empty salvation.
so, God must, on the cross, judge our sins and forgive us at the same time in order to allow for us to form a love relationship with Him. He must also predestine us and know who we are and even set our paths for us, but He must give us the full freedom to choose those paths.
however, if there is only free choice, if we all decide our own fate, and are untouchable, than God has no power, no control, and therefore is not God (since God must retain His power in order to forgive us, help us, etc.) if He has no power over our lives, than He cannot save us from evil, since that might at times limit our free will to choose Him or not. even though it appears that free choice without God's influence will get us where we need to be, it ultimately, on its own, isolates us from the Father since He will not interfere with our choice. the ultimate form of reality, if free choice is all there is, is deism, since God will not interfere in the lives of His creation, and since, we all like sheep have gone astray (isaiah), if we're on our own, to put it bluntly, we're all screwed. just like if all God did was forgive us on the cross, but never judge our sin, we would all go to heaven, no questions asked. at first this seems nice - everyone's going to heaven! but what does that really mean? heaven is where God is. it's the place where we ultimately know and love God and experience the true, infinite bliss of His love. but love requires a choice, and there was no choice in this redemption. so even though we're all saved, none of us are loved enough to choose it. it's flawed and empty salvation.
so, God must, on the cross, judge our sins and forgive us at the same time in order to allow for us to form a love relationship with Him. He must also predestine us and know who we are and even set our paths for us, but He must give us the full freedom to choose those paths.
soooooo.... if you've made it this far, i gotta say you're a trooper. like i said, this is like, a weeks worth of thought, so it's a bunch. i just wanted to hit the ground running after a long break from the blog, and i figured this was something i had handy that might help somebody. i know predestination and whether it's true or not can be a touchy subject - these are my thoughts and the thoughts of some of my very intellectual friends, not necessarily the truth. i also haven't finished the convo, so my friends on the other side(s) might have more to say. however, all of the stuff about the cross is utterly true! He loves you and He went all the way to prove it! if any of y'all are like me, you've been going through a low point spiritually (which i gotta talk about soon!). hold on to Him and His love. He'll getcha through!
God bless!
No comments:
Post a Comment